THE PATH WAS NEVER MEANT TO BE EASY

America loves courage once the danger has passed. Harriet Tubman and the women still building routes to freedom ask what we're willing to risk before history tells us we were right.

Share
THE PATH WAS NEVER MEANT TO BE EASY
Harriet Tubman reimagined for the present day. A nod to the organizer, scout and spy whose intelligence work aided the Union during the Civil War. Editorial illustration for Cloak and State.

Everyone loves courage once it’s safe.

We build statues to it. We name schools after it. We put it on postage stamps and hang portraits of it in government buildings. Eventually, we teach it to children in classrooms where the ending has already been written and everyone knows who the heroes were.

History is wonderfully convenient that way.

Harriet Tubman is now so firmly established in the American imagination as a hero that it can be difficult to remember there was nothing inevitable about becoming one.

Today, Tubman belongs to America. There are monuments bearing her likeness and national historical parks preserving her story. Her image appeared on a United States postage stamp in 1978. She has become one of those rare historical figures whom Americans across ideological lines can comfortably call courageous.

But monuments have a way of making dangerous people seem safe.

The Harriet Tubman we celebrate today was not safe.

She was disruptive. She broke laws. She defied institutions. She interfered with an enormously profitable economic system. And after escaping slavery herself, she made the almost incomprehensible decision to go back.

That is the part of her story I keep returning to.

She went back.

Tubman escaped Maryland in 1849 and made her way to Philadelphia. She could have stopped there. No reasonable person could have accused a formerly enslaved woman of insufficient commitment to freedom because, having somehow secured her own, she decided she would like to keep it.

Instead, over roughly a decade, Tubman returned to Maryland about 13 times and personally led approximately 70 people to freedom, many of them family members and friends. She also gave instructions that helped dozens of others escape.

We know how that story ends.

She didn't.

And I think that distinction matters more than we allow ourselves to admit.

We have developed a habit in America of admiring courage retrospectively. We love the dissenter after the dissent has become consensus. We celebrate the person who stood alone once history has provided them company. We quote the troublemaker after the trouble has been resolved.

It allows all of us to imagine ourselves standing beside them.

Of course I would have helped Harriet. Of course I would have marched. Of course I would have spoken up. Of course I would have been on the right side.

Maybe.

Most of us are extraordinarily brave in historical situations we will never have to encounter. The more interesting question is what we do when the outcome isn't known.

We sometimes talk about people like Tubman as though they were born with some reserve of courage unavailable to the rest of us. Perhaps that makes their lives easier to admire. If Harriet was simply fearless, if she was fundamentally different from ordinary people, then the rest of us are relieved of having to consider what her choices might require of us.

But the historical record gives us something more complicated.

Tubman didn't just possess courage. She developed skills. She learned terrain. She cultivated relationships. She gathered information. She raised money. She assessed risk. She built networks.

During the Civil War, that ability became military intelligence. Tubman served the Union as a nurse and scout, developed a network of informants, and played an important role in the planning and execution of the Combahee River Raid in South Carolina, which liberated hundreds of enslaved people while disrupting Confederate plantations and supply lines.

In other words, Harriet Tubman was not simply brave.

Harriet Tubman was an organizer.

And that may be the part of her legacy we have most thoroughly romanticized out of the story.

Freedom required infrastructure.

Someone had to know the route. Someone had to know which house was safe. Someone had to know whom to trust. Someone had to have the money. Someone had to understand when to leave, where to stop and what to do when the original plan became impossible.

Liberation wasn't simply a belief. Somebody had to build a way out.

That is why I find myself thinking less about whether there could ever be another Harriet Tubman and more about the Harriets already on the ground.

Not replicas of her. History doesn't work that way. The dangers aren't equivalent, the causes aren't interchangeable, and comparing every modern struggle to slavery would diminish the particular horror Tubman confronted.

But the work of building routes? That is still happening all around us. We just don't always recognize it before the monument.

Tarana Burke began the “me too.” movement in 2006, rooted in work with survivors of sexual violence and particularly marginalized communities, including Black women and girls. The hashtag wouldn't explode globally until 2017.

Eleven years.

Think about that. We remember the moment the world started saying #MeToo. We are less likely to remember the years when Tarana Burke was saying it before the world was listening.

That's how we like our movements: at the moment of arrival.

The march. The hashtag. The election. The speech. The cover story. The victory.

We are considerably less interested in Tuesday afternoon in Year Four when there isn't enough money, the meeting has six people in it, nobody important is returning the phone calls and the person building the thing has no idea whether anyone outside that room will ever care.

But that's usually where change lives.

In 2013, Alicia Garza, Patrisse Cullors and Ayọ Tometi, then known as Opal Tometi, created what became #BlackLivesMatter after George Zimmerman was acquitted in the killing of Trayvon Martin. The project grew from a Black-centered organizing effort into a movement whose language traveled around the world.

It is almost difficult now to remember how provocative those three words once seemed.

Black Lives Matter.

Three words that should have been utterly unremarkable became a national argument.

Politicians wrestled with whether they could say them. Critics countered with their own formulations. Protesters were vilified. Organizers were attacked. Americans spent years debating not merely the movement's demands, strategies and politics, all of which were fair subjects for scrutiny, but the phrase itself.

And then something very American happened. The language started becoming institutional.

Corporations adopted it. Brands incorporated it. Universities issued statements. Elected officials who had once approached the phrase gingerly began saying it from podiums.

Adopting the language, of course, is considerably easier than accepting what it demands.

That's one of America's more fascinating rituals.

First, the demand is unreasonable. Then it's controversial. Then it's debated. Then it's adopted. And eventually everyone vaguely remembers having understood the point from the beginning.

We do it in politics too.

In 2011, Glynda Carr and Kimberly Peeler-Allen co-founded Higher Heights because they saw a gap in American political infrastructure: Black women were enormously important as voters, organizers and political workers, yet there was insufficient infrastructure devoted specifically to building their political power and supporting Black women seeking office.

Today, you can barely make it through an election cycle without hearing someone announce that Black women are the backbone of American democracy.

There are panels about us. Reports about us. Fundraising appeals built around us. Election-night analysis about us. Everybody has discovered Black women voters. But somebody had to build it before everybody discovered it.

Someone had to recruit. Someone had to fundraise. Someone had to convince a woman who had never seen someone like herself occupying the office she was considering running for that perhaps she should run anyway.

Someone had to make the calls. Someone had to build the list. Someone had to keep the spreadsheet.

There is no dramatic soundtrack accompanying the spreadsheet. But movements require infrastructure just as surely as they require moments. And that's where the connection to Tubman becomes interesting to me.

These women’s work deserves to be understood on its own terms. But they share something with the tradition Tubman represents. They saw people stranded somewhere between what America promised and what America delivered. And instead of simply describing the distance, they started building routes.

That is what organizers do.

They build a way from here to there before the rest of us are entirely convinced there is possible. And often, they do it without knowing whether anyone will ever build them a monument.

Courage is funny that way. We use the word rather generously now.

A celebrity posts an opinion shared by most of her followers and we call it courageous. A politician criticizes something already unpopular with his voters and we praise his bravery. A corporation releases a carefully vetted statement after lawyers, consultants and communications professionals have determined that saying nothing presents a greater reputational risk than saying something.

Sometimes those things require conviction.

But courage? I think courage should have an invoice.

It doesn't have to cost your life. It shouldn't require recklessness. But there should be something on the other side of the decision that you would rather not lose.

A job. A friendship. A promotion. Money. Reputation. Access. An invitation. The approval of someone powerful. The comfort of knowing everyone at the table still likes you.

Tubman's invoice was almost unimaginably high. Capture could have meant violent punishment and re-enslavement. The people traveling with her were taking similarly enormous risks. Even the free Black people and abolitionists who assisted the Underground Railroad operated within a dangerous legal and political environment.

But this is precisely why we should be careful about making courage synonymous only with mortal danger.

Most of us will never be asked to risk what Tubman risked.

Thank God.

But all of us will eventually encounter the smaller invoice. And I wonder whether we recognize it when it arrives. Because actual courage is inconvenient.

It interrupts things. It makes dinner uncomfortable. It asks the question everyone has quietly agreed not to ask. It refuses to accept that proximity to power is the same thing as possessing it. And perhaps most dangerously, courage threatens arrangements that are working perfectly well for the people benefiting from them.

Which brings us to access.

I think we underestimate how effectively access can discipline people. Get invited into enough rooms and eventually you become reluctant to criticize the room. Know the governor personally and suddenly the governor's failures have context. Know the billionaire and what looked outrageous from a distance becomes complicated up close. Know the editor, the donor, the university president, the celebrity, the CEO and eventually there is no one left you can comfortably offend.

No one has to buy you. Sometimes they simply have to invite you. That's one of the quieter ways power protects itself. It is also why the women doing the work before the invitations arrive are so interesting.

Before the awards. Before the honorary degrees. Before the magazine profiles. Before the organization has a development department and a communications strategy. Before everyone agrees the issue matters. There is usually someone sitting in a folding chair somewhere trying to convince five other people that something needs to change.

That person may never become famous. She may never trend. She may not lead the movement that eventually gets credit. She may spend 20 years doing work that history condenses into a paragraph. But she is there.

Somewhere in America right now, there is a woman doing work that we will someday describe as obvious.

Maybe she's organizing mothers. Maybe she's defending voting rights. Maybe she's building something around maternal health. Maybe she's fighting book bans. Maybe she's creating a political organization. Maybe she's sitting in a church basement. Maybe she's working from her kitchen table. Maybe she has 400 followers. Maybe nobody important knows her name.

Yet.

That is the woman I want us to get better at seeing.

Not because every activist is right. Not because every movement deserves vindication. Not because disruption is inherently virtuous. Conviction does not exempt anyone from scrutiny, and history is full of people who were passionately certain and disastrously wrong.

But because we have become too comfortable outsourcing moral clarity to history. We wait for the answer key. Then we congratulate ourselves for getting the answer right.

That is why asking whether we would have helped Harriet Tubman is such an uninteresting question.

Of course you say yes. You know how slavery ends. You know Tubman becomes a hero. You know which answer earns you the moral gold star.

I am much more interested in what you believe right now, while the ending remains unwritten. What do you believe strongly enough that you're willing to lose something for it?

Not die for it. Not destroy your life. Something.

Would you lose an invitation? Would you risk a promotion? Would you challenge the person who can open the next door for you? Would you say publicly what everyone at the table says privately after the person with power leaves? Would you remain committed to a principle if practicing it meant someone you admire stopped admiring you?

And perhaps the most uncomfortable question of all:

Would you recognize a Harriet before everybody started calling her one? Because Harriet Tubman did not arrive to us as Harriet Tubman, American icon.

She arrived as Araminta Ross, born enslaved on Maryland's Eastern Shore. Later, she brought those same skills, gathering information, cultivating relationships, planning, and navigating to her Civil War service and beyond.

She didn't know a National Historical Park would someday preserve her story. She didn't know schoolchildren would learn her name. She didn't know Americans would eventually turn her into a symbol of courage. She simply knew there were people on one side of freedom who needed to get to the other. And she knew a route.

Maybe that's the part of Harriet Tubman's legacy worth recovering from the monuments.

Not merely the bravery. The building. The organizing. The going back. The stubborn belief that freedom isn't particularly meaningful if you are content to enjoy yours while everybody else remains trapped.

History loves the moment. Change is usually built in the years before it.

And perhaps somewhere, right now, another woman is building a route the rest of us don't yet understand. The safest place to stand with courage is always in the future, after someone else has already paid its price.

Harriet Tubman's life asks something considerably harder of us: Where will we stand while the outcome is still uncertain?


Independent journalism doesn't happen by accident.

Cloak & State examines the people, institutions, and decisions shaping power, money, culture, and society. Our inaugural issue is open to everyone. 

Subscribe to stay informed, stay dangerous, and be part of what comes next.